Home > Community > Competitive 'Wittig' vs 'Peterson' C=C bond formation
Upvote

27

Downvote
+ Kinetics
+ Chemistry
Posted by
Admin?and

Competitive 'Wittig' vs 'Peterson' C=C bond formation

B J Quinn  Follow

You're looking for the faster rate, so given that a triphenylphosphonium (ever see a model of one of these things?) is a lot bulkier than a trimethylsilyl group, I would argue that the sterics is the main driving force behind the selectivity of this reaction.

More

Upvote

VOTE

Downvote
John R. Green  Follow
Good point : ) I guess only way to really find out if its sterics or oxophilicity would be to repeat the experiment with the $\mathrm{PMe_3}$ system.More
Upvote

VOTE

Downvote
Chun Xu  Follow

Seems like the silicon atom is more oxophilic as compared to the phosphorus atom. This could in principal be explained by the higher strength of the $\ce{Si-O}$ bond, as indicated by the dissociation energies $D$ (see http://www.wiredchemist.com/chemistry/data/bond_energies_lengths.html):$$\begin{array}{ccc}\hline\textbf{Bond} & \textbf{Dissociation energy / kJ mol}\mathbf{^{-1}} & \textbf{Bond length / pm} \\\hline\ce{Si-O} & 452 & 163 \\\ce{P-O} & 335 & 163 \\ \hline\end{array}$$The $\ce{Si-O}$ bond is stronger thus given an explanation why the Peterson olefination is favoured.It seems that the bond lengths $r_b$ are the same, though.

By the way, a nice discussion of oxophilicity was given recently in Inorg. Chem. 2016, 55 (18), 9461.

More

Upvote

VOTE

Downvote