Home > Community > Formyl chloride naming
Upvote

35

Downvote
+ Chemistry
+ Nomenclature
Posted by
Michael Hughes

Formyl chloride naming

Chris Johnston  Follow

Welcome to parallel worlds of trivial and systematic names. We also use formic acid, acetic acid, acetyl chloride.

You can name them all systematically as methanoyl chloride, methanoic acid, ethanoic acid and ethanoyl chloride. But in the real lab life, nobody call them like that.

Formyl chloride has its name fromformyl- as acyl derived from formic acid, the same as acetyl- from acetic acid.

Technically, formyl chloride is an aldehyde as well, as formyl is de facto an aldehyde group, being formally a member of the serie :

$$\ce{Cl-CH2OH <> Cl-CHO <> Cl-COOH}$$

But by naming conventions, both trivial and systematic, being a derivate of an acid replacing $\ce{OH}$ by $\ce{Cl}$ takes precedence to naming it as an aldehyde.

As a sidenote, it is rather funny aldehyde names are derived from the respective acids and not alcohols. Because the aldehyde etymology says aldehyde="alcohol dehydrogenatus", so it could be as well methylaldehyde and ethylaldehyde, instead of formaldehyde and acetaldehyde.

More

Upvote

VOTE

Downvote
Joseph A Jansen Jr  Follow
Only thanks to your answer did I notice that analysing formyl chloride as $\ce{CHO}+\ce{Cl}$ makes sense, too =DMore
Upvote

VOTE

Downvote
Emily Atziaras  Follow
Why cant I take CHO in formyl chloride as aldehyde?More
Upvote

VOTE

Downvote
Florens de Wit  Follow
Technically, it is an aldehyde as well, as formyl is de facto an aldehyde group. But by naming conventions, both trivial and systematic, being a derivate of an acid replacing OH by Cl takes precedence.More
Upvote

VOTE

Downvote