Home > Community > Why is platinum denser than gold?
Upvote

25

Downvote
+ Density
+ Chemistry
Posted by
Aarij Asher

Why is platinum denser than gold?

Ashley Kjerstin  Follow

Since OP is still in the high school, I'll try to explain it simply as possible using mathematical manipulation (hoping OP is more familiar with mathematics than chemistry).

Both gold and platinum consist of same crystal packing called body-centered cubic, which is illustrated in following diagram:

Crystal structure of gold & platinum

Crystal studies of both gold and platinum has revealed that the lengths of their cubic unit cells ($a$) are $\pu{407.82 pm}$ and $\pu{392.31 pm}$, respectively. If you inspect closely, you would realize that each of eight corner atoms shares with eight unit cells while each of six face-centered atoms shares with only two unit cells. Thus, total atoms per unit cell $= 8 \times \frac{1}{8} + 6 \times \frac{1}{2} = 4$. Keep in mind that $a$ is depend on the atomic radius of each metal and how closely they packed against each other against some concerning forces (e.g., van der Waal's). For example, the experimental finding has been reported that the closest $\ce{Au-Au}$ separation is $\pu{288.4 pm}$ while that of $\ce{Pt-Pt}$ is $\pu{277.5 pm}$. These values imply that the metallic radius of gold is $\pu{144.2 pm}$ and that of platinum is $\pu{139 pm}$. This would cover the quote "the radii of the atoms and the bond lengths within the crystal lattice."

Based on the value of $a$ and number of atoms per unit cell for each metal, you can calculate the molar volume of each metal ($V_\mathrm{Metal}$):

$$V_\ce{Au} = a_\ce{Au}^3 \times \frac{1}{\pu{4 atoms}} \times N_A \\= (\pu{407.82 pm})^3 \times \left(\frac{\pu{1 cm}}{\pu{10^10 pm}}\right)^3 \times \frac{1}{\pu{4 atoms}} \times \pu{6.022 \times 10^{23} atoms\:mol-1} = \pu{10.21 cm3mol-1}$$

and similarly,

$$V_\ce{Pt} = a_\ce{Pt}^3 \times \frac{1}{\pu{4 atoms}} \times N_A \\= (\pu{392.31 pm})^3 \times \left(\frac{\pu{1 cm}}{\pu{10^10 pm}}\right)^3 \times \frac{1}{\pu{4 atoms}} \times \pu{6.022 \times 10^{23} atoms\:mol-1} = \pu{9.09 cm3mol-1}$$

Once we know the molar volume of each metal, we can calculate the density ($d$) by using $d=\frac{\text {molar mass}}{\text {molar volume}}$:

$$d_\ce{Au} = \frac{\pu{196.97 gmol-1}}{\pu{10.21 cm3mol-1}} = \pu{19.29 gcm-3}$$

$$d_\ce{Pt} = \frac{\pu{195.08 gmol-1}}{\pu{9.09 cm3mol-1}} = \pu{21.46 gcm-3}$$

Therefore, it is true that $d_\ce{Pt} \gt d_\ce{Au}$.


Relevant resources:

  1. John W. Arblaster, In Selected Values of the Crystallographic Properties of Elements; ASM International: Material Park, OH, 2018 (ISBN-13: 978-1627081542).
  2. Arnulf Maeland, Ted B. Flanagan, “Lattice Spacings of Gold–Palladium Alloys,” Canadian Journal of Physics 1964, 42(11), 2364-2366 (https://doi.org/10.1139/p64-213).
  3. https://www.webelements.com/gold/crystal_structure.html
  4. https://www.webelements.com/platinum/crystal_structure.html

More

Upvote

VOTE

Downvote
Jim Henderson  Follow
@ShubhangWalavalkar In a nutshell, unless you are looking at crystalline noble gases the atoms will be in some way bonded to each other. How exactly these bonds are formed in different elements is a rather complex topic but as a rule of thumb if all other things (such as number of shells) are equal a shorter bond length means stronger or more bonds. Comparing gold and platinum, the shorter $\ce{Pt-Pt}$ distance can be rationalised as a stronger or more effective bond – in an extremely simplified manner. Once you know the bond length, the length of the unit cell is simple trigonometry.More
Upvote

VOTE

Downvote
Gary Viveiros  Follow
I cant give a direct answer to that, but one of our crystallography persons would do. Im pure organic chemist. :-)More
Upvote

VOTE

Downvote
Esther Yeboah  Follow
Thank you Sir. I understood everything. But one thing I couldnt grasp is on what basis does the length of cubic unit cell depends upon?More
Upvote

VOTE

Downvote
Doug Robb  Follow
The stronger bonding in metallic platinum is confirmed by its higher melting point (1768 C for Pt, 1064 C for Au).More
Upvote

VOTE

Downvote