Home >
Community >
Why is potassium ferrocyanide considered safe for consumption, when it is just one reaction away from the highly toxic potassium cyanide?
Upvote
31
Downvote
+ Chemistry
+ Toxicity
Posted by
MR HARRY
Why is potassium ferrocyanide considered safe for consumption, when it is just one reaction away from the highly toxic potassium cyanide?
Under biological conditions it is almost impossible to release HCN
Free cyanide can be released from potassium ferrocyanide by heating or by strongly acidic conditions (and some heat). Neither of these conditions is possible in a living organism.
The reason why this is so is because the cyanide ligands are very strongly bound to the iron (in slightly more technical terms the dissociation constant is very, very small (ca 10-24)). Most of the mechanisms that generate cyanide require much more violent chemical attack: waiting for the cyanide to dissociate and then protonating it to give deadly HCN will never result in a notable amount of NCH. This means that, in biological systems, ferrocyanide is effectively inert.
This explains why the LD50 in mice, for example, is about 6g/kg which is a lot ([see the safety info here]2 for both ferri- and ferrocyanides).
It is also worth noting that food safety authorities have studied the compounds and agree that:
The Panel concluded that ferrocyanides (E 535–538) are of no safety concern in these current authorised use and use levels.
So, while it might look like you are "one reaction away from cyanide" in practical terms this is not remotely true.
Under biological conditions it is almost impossible to release HCN
Free cyanide can be released from potassium ferrocyanide by heating or by strongly acidic conditions (and some heat). Neither of these conditions is possible in a living organism.
The reason why this is so is because the cyanide ligands are very strongly bound to the iron (in slightly more technical terms the dissociation constant is very, very small (ca 10-24)). Most of the mechanisms that generate cyanide require much more violent chemical attack: waiting for the cyanide to dissociate and then protonating it to give deadly HCN will never result in a notable amount of NCH. This means that, in biological systems, ferrocyanide is effectively inert.
This explains why the LD50 in mice, for example, is about 6g/kg which is a lot ([see the safety info here]2 for both ferri- and ferrocyanides).
It is also worth noting that food safety authorities have studied the compounds and agree that:
The Panel concluded that ferrocyanides (E 535–538) are of no safety concern in these current authorised use and use levels.
So, while it might look like you are "one reaction away from cyanide" in practical terms this is not remotely true.
Thanks for reading the question fully and taking the time to answer! Since it is not conclusive I wont mark it as an accepted answer. In my naive opinion, anti-caking property seems like a small benefit compared to the potential downside. BTW, I cant access the linked article (some problem with cookies / javascript).More
This is an attempt to answer what I think might be more the spirit of the question than literal translation, because I think @Jans comment (2nd on OP) answers the exact question very wellMore
@nick012000 Citric acid (principal acid in lemon juice) isnt notably stronger than acetic acid. Besides, how are you going to get enough ferrocyanide to notice anything given how little there is in table salt?More
Under biological conditions it is almost impossible to release HCN
Free cyanide can be released from potassium ferrocyanide by heating or by strongly acidic conditions (and some heat). Neither of these conditions is possible in a living organism.
The reason why this is so is because the cyanide ligands are very strongly bound to the iron (in slightly more technical terms the dissociation constant is very, very small (ca 10-24)). Most of the mechanisms that generate cyanide require much more violent chemical attack: waiting for the cyanide to dissociate and then protonating it to give deadly HCN will never result in a notable amount of NCH. This means that, in biological systems, ferrocyanide is effectively inert.
This explains why the LD50 in mice, for example, is about 6g/kg which is a lot ([see the safety info here]2 for both ferri- and ferrocyanides).
It is also worth noting that food safety authorities have studied the compounds and agree that:
So, while it might look like you are "one reaction away from cyanide" in practical terms this is not remotely true.
Under biological conditions it is almost impossible to release HCN
Free cyanide can be released from potassium ferrocyanide by heating or by strongly acidic conditions (and some heat). Neither of these conditions is possible in a living organism.
The reason why this is so is because the cyanide ligands are very strongly bound to the iron (in slightly more technical terms the dissociation constant is very, very small (ca 10-24)). Most of the mechanisms that generate cyanide require much more violent chemical attack: waiting for the cyanide to dissociate and then protonating it to give deadly HCN will never result in a notable amount of NCH. This means that, in biological systems, ferrocyanide is effectively inert.
This explains why the LD50 in mice, for example, is about 6g/kg which is a lot ([see the safety info here]2 for both ferri- and ferrocyanides).
It is also worth noting that food safety authorities have studied the compounds and agree that:
So, while it might look like you are "one reaction away from cyanide" in practical terms this is not remotely true.
More
VOTE
VOTE
VOTE
VOTE
VOTE
VOTE