Home >
Community >
Why is the calomel electrode widely preferred despite its toxicity?
Upvote
24
Downvote
+ Safety
+ Chemistry
+ Electrochemistry
+ Toxicity
Posted by
Abrar Hafiz
Why is the calomel electrode widely preferred despite its toxicity?
[…] Why and how chemist are still able to perform experiments using Calomel electrodes despite its toxicity? […]
I mostly used non-aqueous silver electrodes as a reference for my measurements in acetonitrile.
But I wouldn't be afraid to use a saturated calomel electrode (SCE) when necessary. We have recently discussed the toxicity of mercury metal and I think it is largely overrated.
As far as $\ce{Hg2Cl2}$ (calomel), the other mercury component in the SCE is concerned, have a look as the wikipedia article that you have cited yourself. The solubility is extremely low ($\mathrm{2.3\ mg\cdot l^{-1}}$) and the ${\mathrm{LD_{50}}}$ is $\mathrm{210\ mg\cdot kg^{-1}}$ (rat, oral uptake). This isn't overly dramatic either, when compared to the infamous potassium cyanide (${\mathrm{LD_{50}}}$ $\mathrm{5\ mg\cdot kg^{-1}}$, rat, oral uptake).
Actually, calomel had medical uses :)
In an article on Venereal disease prevention, the author writes:
[…] the absence of therapeutic modalities spurred the United States Armed Services to utilize Credé's solution for urethral irrigation and locally applied calomel ointment for prophylactic purposes in World War I […]
As far as the toxicity is concerned, both mercury metal and mercury(I)chloride are by no means comparable with dimethylmercury.
[…] Why and how chemist are still able to perform experiments using Calomel electrodes despite its toxicity? […]
I mostly used non-aqueous silver electrodes as a reference for my measurements in acetonitrile.
But I wouldn't be afraid to use a saturated calomel electrode (SCE) when necessary. We have recently discussed the toxicity of mercury metal and I think it is largely overrated.
As far as $\ce{Hg2Cl2}$ (calomel), the other mercury component in the SCE is concerned, have a look as the wikipedia article that you have cited yourself. The solubility is extremely low ($\mathrm{2.3\ mg\cdot l^{-1}}$) and the ${\mathrm{LD_{50}}}$ is $\mathrm{210\ mg\cdot kg^{-1}}$ (rat, oral uptake). This isn't overly dramatic either, when compared to the infamous potassium cyanide (${\mathrm{LD_{50}}}$ $\mathrm{5\ mg\cdot kg^{-1}}$, rat, oral uptake).
Actually, calomel had medical uses :)
In an article on Venereal disease prevention, the author writes:
[…] the absence of therapeutic modalities spurred the United States Armed Services to utilize Credé's solution for urethral irrigation and locally applied calomel ointment for prophylactic purposes in World War I […]
As far as the toxicity is concerned, both mercury metal and mercury(I)chloride are by no means comparable with dimethylmercury.
I mostly used non-aqueous silver electrodes as a reference for my measurements in acetonitrile.
But I wouldn't be afraid to use a saturated calomel electrode (SCE) when necessary. We have recently discussed the toxicity of mercury metal and I think it is largely overrated.
As far as $\ce{Hg2Cl2}$ (calomel), the other mercury component in the SCE is concerned, have a look as the wikipedia article that you have cited yourself. The solubility is extremely low ($\mathrm{2.3\ mg\cdot l^{-1}}$) and the ${\mathrm{LD_{50}}}$ is $\mathrm{210\ mg\cdot kg^{-1}}$ (rat, oral uptake). This isn't overly dramatic either, when compared to the infamous potassium cyanide (${\mathrm{LD_{50}}}$ $\mathrm{5\ mg\cdot kg^{-1}}$, rat, oral uptake).
Actually, calomel had medical uses :)
In an article on Venereal disease prevention, the author writes:
As far as the toxicity is concerned, both mercury metal and mercury(I)chloride are by no means comparable with dimethylmercury.
I mostly used non-aqueous silver electrodes as a reference for my measurements in acetonitrile.
But I wouldn't be afraid to use a saturated calomel electrode (SCE) when necessary. We have recently discussed the toxicity of mercury metal and I think it is largely overrated.
As far as $\ce{Hg2Cl2}$ (calomel), the other mercury component in the SCE is concerned, have a look as the wikipedia article that you have cited yourself. The solubility is extremely low ($\mathrm{2.3\ mg\cdot l^{-1}}$) and the ${\mathrm{LD_{50}}}$ is $\mathrm{210\ mg\cdot kg^{-1}}$ (rat, oral uptake). This isn't overly dramatic either, when compared to the infamous potassium cyanide (${\mathrm{LD_{50}}}$ $\mathrm{5\ mg\cdot kg^{-1}}$, rat, oral uptake).
Actually, calomel had medical uses :)
In an article on Venereal disease prevention, the author writes:
As far as the toxicity is concerned, both mercury metal and mercury(I)chloride are by no means comparable with dimethylmercury.
More
VOTE