Home >
Community >
What are the specific dangers associated with Grignard reagents?
Upvote
29
Downvote
+ Safety
Posted by
Kigen Denis
What are the specific dangers associated with Grignard reagents?
I have to disagree your position entirely.
Every chemical has associated hazards, with even the most unassuming chemicals having the potential to cause severe harm if not fatality.
However, the actual risk to the chemist is often severely minimised by taking sensible precautions, understanding the hazards, and working under a controlled set of conditions.
The whole purpose of organic chemistry education, especially the purpose of organic chemistry labs is to teach students how they should safely handle chemicals, not to tell them that they're too risky.
Every chemical has associated hazards, with even the most unassuming chemicals having the potential to cause severe harm if not fatality.
However, the actual risk to the chemist is often severely minimised by taking sensible precautions, understanding the hazards, and working under a controlled set of conditions.
The whole purpose of organic chemistry education, especially the purpose of organic chemistry labs is to teach students how they should safely handle chemicals, not to tell them that they're too risky.
Perhaps we can continue this conversation in chat, as I think its worth exploring, but the stack exchange model doesnt encourage opinion based questions and answer.More
While I appreciate your point (yet do not agree with it), its not at all what Im asking about. I want to know if anyone has specifically encountered any kind of injury resulting from Grignard reagents mainly as an issue of personal curiosity. However, to your point, are you saying you would allow students in a second-year course (1st year of o-chem, after a year of g-chem) to work with potassium cyanide or lithium aluminum hydride? Im talking about a class of 24 students each working independently. Even with the most careful supervision thats not a risk I would be willing to take.More
I have to disagree your position entirely.
Every chemical has associated hazards, with even the most unassuming chemicals having the potential to cause severe harm if not fatality.
However, the actual risk to the chemist is often severely minimised by taking sensible precautions, understanding the hazards, and working under a controlled set of conditions.
The whole purpose of organic chemistry education, especially the purpose of organic chemistry labs is to teach students how they should safely handle chemicals, not to tell them that they're too risky.
I have to disagree your position entirely.
Every chemical has associated hazards, with even the most unassuming chemicals having the potential to cause severe harm if not fatality.
However, the actual risk to the chemist is often severely minimised by taking sensible precautions, understanding the hazards, and working under a controlled set of conditions.
The whole purpose of organic chemistry education, especially the purpose of organic chemistry labs is to teach students how they should safely handle chemicals, not to tell them that they're too risky.
More
VOTE
VOTE
VOTE